GET TO KNOW US

Great American has a well diversified book of business including: refinances, purchases, REO’s, HUD’s, short sales, and commercial transactions. Great American understands that there is a family behind every file.

Customer service is the foundation of all great companies and we instill this in our knowledgeable and friendly staff. We are a title company that excels in an excellent overall closing experience. We have positioned ourselves in the real estate market as a leader in both efficiency and service and we look forward to serving you and your family for any and all of your real estate needs.

Jason Kiley

Owner

Jason Kiley

Owner

The Ohio State University Alum. Founded GATA February 2007. Resides in Galena. Favorite Charity: Make A Wish.

Brenda Gerschutz

Managing Partner

Brenda Gerschutz

Managing Partner

University of Toledo Alum. Joined GATA June 2013. Resides in Worthington. Favorite Charity: Hunt for Hope.

Amy Bivenour

Reception

Amy Bivenour

Reception

The Ohio State University Alum. Joined GATA February 2016. Northland High School Alum, Joined GATA June 2022, Favorite Charity: Smile Train.

Michelle Pence

Business Development / Sales

Michelle Pence

Business Development / Sales

Indiana University Alum. Joined GATA March 2016. Resides in Columbus. Favorite Charity: Humane Society.

Karen Miller

Business Development / Sales

Karen Miller

Business Development / Sales

Joliet West High School Alum. Joined GATA October 2019. Resides in Dublin. Favorite Charity: American Foundation for Suicide Prevention.

Whitney Fanello

Business Development /Sales

Whitney Fanello

Business Development /Sales

North Central State College Alum, Joined GATA September 2022, Resides in Mansfield, Ohio, Favorite Charity: PSI- Postpartum Support Interna

Marty Qualls

Office Manager

Marty Qualls

Office Manager

Westerville South High School Alum. Joined GATA in April 2016. Resides in Westerville. Favorite Charity:Sunrise Sanctuary.

Stephanie Matthews

Post Closing/Funding

Stephanie Matthews

Post Closing/Funding

Westerville South High School Alum. Joined GATA June 2018. Resides in Westerville. Favorite Charity: The Ohio Justice and Policy Center.

Matt Buxton

Post Closing/Funding

Matt Buxton

Post Closing/Funding

Tiffin University Alum. Joined GATA February 2007. Resides in Columbus. Favorite Charity: Shriners Hospitals for Children.

Christina Dellinger

Processor

Christina Dellinger

Processor

University of Northwest Ohio Alum. Resides in Marysville. Joined GATA February 2013. Favorite Charity: Union County Humane Society.

Mandy Thompson

Processor

Mandy Thompson

Processor

Johnston Monroe High School Alum. Resides in Fredericktown. Joined GATA in April 2014. Favorite Charity: American Heart Association.

Betsy Ballinger

Business Development /Sales

Betsy Ballinger

Business Development /Sales

The Ohio State University Alum, Joined GATA September, 2022, Resides in Marion. Charity: Alzheimer’s Association

Deanna Hails

Escrow Officer

Deanna Hails

Escrow Officer

Ohio University Alum. Resides in Pickerington. Joined GATA July 2017. Favorite Charity: Mission 22.

Misty Argo

Escrow Officer

Misty Argo

Escrow Officer

The Ohio State University Alum. Resides in Galena. Joined GATA May 2015. Favorite Charity: American Red Cross.

Danielle Cavaner

Policy

Danielle Cavaner

Policy

Meadow Brook High School Alum. Resides in Westerville. Joined GATA in October 2017. Favorite Charity: Pediatrics for Cancer.

Kris Rutan

Escrow Officer

Kris Rutan

Escrow Officer

Westland High School Alum Resides in Mount Vernon Joined GATA May 2019 Favorite Charity: Together We Live

Gisela Watkinson

Escrow Officer

Gisela Watkinson

Escrow Officer

Westerville North High School Alum Resides in Cardington, OH Joined GATA in Jan 2020 Favorite Charity: Susan G Komen Foundation

Nicole Evans

Title Commitments

Nicole Evans

Title Commitments

Rushmore Academy Alum Resides in Delaware, OH Joined GATA July 2016   Favorite Charity: ASPCA

Abby Skinner

Processor

Abby Skinner

Processor

Fairfield Union Alum, Joined GATA September 2021, Resides in Bremen, Favorite Charity: The C Neese Foundation