Constantly Striving to Earn Your Business

Great American Title Agency was founded in 2007 by Jason Kiley, and has a well diversified book of business including: refinances, purchases, REO's, HUD's, short sales, and commercial transactions.

Because there's a family behind every file

When purchasing a new home or refinancing an existing mortgage, do you know what transpires from the time of application to the day of settlement? At Great American Title Agency, we realize your home is your most valuable asset. We understand the stress associated with purchasing or refinancing a home and are available to answer any questions or concerns you may have regarding your settlement. Our staff of dedicated professionals will guide you through the entire process and will assure that you are protected against adverse title claims or risks long after your settlement.

We are vetted and verified by Stewart Title and were their 2016 number one remitting agent in Ohio.

We work hard for you and your clients every single day...

Prior to Closing

Conduct Title Search, Coordinate all aspects of title services with appropriate parties, Prepare all necessary documents, Schedule settlement.

During Closing

Account for all funds, Review closing documents, Disburse all mortgage loan or sale proceeds.

After Closing

Satisfy all lender requirements, Record Transfer Documents, Issue Title Insurance Policy.

Document Upload







Meet Our Team

Jason Kiley



Alma Mater: The Ohio State University
Founded Great American Title Agency February 2007
Resides in Galena
Favorite Charity: Make A Wish

Sherry Long

Account Manager


Alma Mater: Youngstown State University
Joined Great American Title Agency August 2007
Brian Saunders Foundation and The Battered Women's Shelter
Favorite Charity:

Mike Barker

Account Manager


Alma Mater: The Ohio State University
Joined Great American Title Agency March 2014
Resides in Powell
Favorite Charity: Teen Suicide Prevention through GDRA

Brenda Gerschutz

Account Manager


Alma Mater: University of Toledo
Joined Great American Title Agency June 2013
Resides in Worthington
Favorite Charity: Hunt for Hope

Wendi Armstrong

Executive Assistant


Alma Mater: The Ohio State University
Joined Great American Title Agency February 2016
Resides in New Albany
Favorite Charity: Smile Train

Michelle Colwell

Executive Assistant


Alma Mater: Indiana University
Joined Great American Title Agency March 2016
Resides in Columbus
Favorite Charity: Humane Society